
Indonesia Asks Google to Explain 19,000 YouTube Takedowns

Indonesia's digital ministry has asked Google to justify in writing why it removed more than 19,000 YouTube channels supportive of the Indonesian government, saying the takedowns risk being misread. The request followed a meeting with Google Indonesia representatives, and the ministry wants the methodology, the review process, how accuracy is measured and the detection error rate.

The number comes from Google's own quarterly influence operations bulletin. In the third quarter edition released at the end of last month, the company said more than 19,000 channels supportive of the Indonesian government and its administration were terminated over that quarter, putting Indonesia top of the list of countries tied to the largest number of removals, ahead of China and Russia.
And the ministry is pressing on the specifics. Its senior official Mediodecci Lustarini said the request was for a written explanatory note with examples, detailing the parameters and methods used to detect and act against accounts that were ultimately terminated, and the ministry also asked how Google determined where the operators behind the content were located.
Google's answer was general. Asked about its removal criteria, the spike in third quarter takedowns and the government's request, a spokesperson told Reuters the company routinely disrupts coordinated influence operations as part of global efforts to protect its platforms including YouTube, and that it consistently enforces its policies regardless of the political viewpoints expressed.
The timing gives the story its edge. The removals came as President Prabowo Subianto's approval rating slid to 51 per cent by the third quarter, one of the periods Google tracked, from about 80 per cent a year earlier, with dissatisfaction building over the economy and his flagship social programmes.
And Google offered no political context. It did not mention the Indonesian political backdrop or explain why it judged the accounts part of coordinated influence operations, which is precisely the gap the ministry says it wants filled with evidence rather than assurance.
The wider question is one every platform faces in the region. A takedown list published quarterly, without the underlying methodology or an error rate, asks governments and readers to trust a judgement they cannot inspect, and Jakarta has now asked for the working.
Google removed more than 19,000 pro-government Indonesian YouTube channels in the third quarter
Indonesia tops the countries with the most channels removed, ahead of China and Russia
The ministry wants Google's methodology, review process and detection error rate
Google says it enforces its policies regardless of political viewpoint
Prabowo's approval rating fell to 51 per cent in July from about 80 per cent
Source: Reuters


